I will admit openly that I spend a lot of time on the internet. I read blogs and peruse news and lifestyle pages like
Daily Life. Recently, I have noticed the term "privilege" being bandied about with alarming frequency. As in, white privilege. Heterosexual privilege. Cis privilege. Male privilege. Educational privilege. It is being used as a weapon in arguments that should be trying to make the world a better place through striving for equality and the rejection of prejudice, but for whose side?
It has got to stop.
My biggest problem with this term is that it is so limiting and can be used in such hateful ways that it detracts from the power of a balanced conversation. I have noticed the term "Check your privilege" being used as a way of shutting down opposition - it's essentially the same as saying "You're wrong, so I am not going to listen to you." My problem is that it is a roadblock used by the people who have been oppressed because of their ethnicity, sexuality, gender, or income when everyone should be working together to try to make the world a better place.
I read an
article yesterday about a speech Joss Whedon gave about feminism, in which he outlined his problems with the word "feminist". He was panned in the article for this, and because he's white and male, the notion of "privilege" reared its ugly head once again. My problem with this terminology is that it says "You were born lucky, therefore you don't understand and you don't get to have an opinion about this", which in itself is another form of oppression. It assumes that the privileged cannot possibly have researched into the treatment of women or the historical and current oppression of societal groups. It assumes that the privileged cannot have developed any sense of empathy or compassion over the course of their lives. It assumes that the privileged involve themselves in, or comment on issues for kicks - slumming it, if you will - because there is no way that they could
actually care about this stuff from their pedestal view of the world. It blocks the opinions by fault of birth - no one gets to pick to whom they are born, the colour of their skin, their gender, but by god, can you be made to suffer for it.
Another example was one I found on Tumblr a while ago, where an African-American man told a white man to "check his privilege" because of the colour of his skin, and followed it up with a diagram of a slave ship from the 18th century. What followed was a spectacular rebuttal where the white guy shut down the notion of his own privilege, because his (white) family tree was descended from Lithuanian and Polish serfs who had emigrated to the USA in the 19th century in hopes for a better life. He resented the whitewashing of anyone with pale skin as being involved in the slave trade, because for a lot of people it was just not the case. The African-American man insinuating that he had historical blood on his hands was racist, but shutting down the argument because of skin colour privilege was his weapon. I particularly related to this, because I personally want a world that is colourblind, where people aren't judged for the colour of their skin no matter what shade it is. Skin colour shouldn't matter in schools, workplaces, universities, relationships, neighbourhoods. I have been accused of racism by proxy because I'm white and my ancestors have lived in Australia for nearly two centuries - throughout the time of the Stolen Generations and before Indigenous land rights and recognition. My family were shipped out from Ireland as convicts, but that doesn't really matter when my skin is pale. I am privileged, don't you see. I don't get to have a voice on issues like racism.
Maybe I'm just a hippy, because I truly believe that the only way that equality will be reached will be for members of all areas of our society to talk to each other and work together despite the longstanding oppressions and irregardless of where everyone has come from. I believe that men who want equality for people of all genders can consider themselves feminist, or have issues with the word feminism because they want the same thing for everyone. I have issues with the word feminism, but because I am an educated woman, this is ok.
We need to stop shutting down arguments with this word. It is counterproductive and ignorant. We need to be able to have arguments and disagree from all sides of the table because that is the only way that we are going to be able to make any progress. And I say that from my position as so done who has been very lucky in where and when I was born, but who recognises that this is not the case for everyone.